Abstract:AIM:To compare the clinical efficacy of defocus rigid gas permeable contact lenses(RGPCL)and highly aspherical lenslets(HAL)for myopia control in children and adolescents with moderate to high myopia.
METHODS:A retrospective study was conducted, enrolling patients aged 8-17 y with moderate to high myopia who presented to Sichuan Eye Hospital, Aier Eye Hospital Group between January 2022 and January 2024. Subjects were divided into the RGPCL group and the HAL group according to myopia correction modalities. Refractive diopters, axial length, corneal curvature, and visual quality were examined at 6 and 12 mo after lens wear, and relevant data were statistically analyzed.
RESULTS:A total of 96 eyes from 96 cases were enrolled, with 48 cases(48 eyes, 8 males and 40 females)allocated to the RGPCL group with a median age of 12.00(11.50, 15.00)y, and 48 cases(48 eyes, 14 males and 34 females)to the HAL group with a median age of 13.00(12.00,14.00)y. At the 6-month follow-up, no significant changes in spherical diopters were observed in either group relative to baseline. Spherical diopters increased in both groups at the 12-month visit, with a significantly smaller increment in the RGPCL group(P<0.01). At the 6- and 12-month follow-up visits, the magnitude of changes in cylindrical refractive power was markedly larger in the RGPCL group relative to the HAL group(P<0.01). At the 6-and 12-month follow-up visits, axial length in both groups had increased relative to baseline, and no significant intergroup difference was detected in axial elongation(P>0.05). At 6 and 12 mo of lens wear, no significant difference in K1,K2 was found in the HAL group compared with baseline, while the K2 value decreased significantly in the RGPCL group(P<0.0167). The RGPCL group achieved substantially higher scores in four domains including visual clarity, image scaling, glare tolerance, visual field range and total at both follow-up time points(all P<0.001).
CONCLUSION:Defocus RGPCL yields superior performance in slowing the progression of spherical and cylindrical, as well as providing better overall visual experience, when compared with HAL.
