[关键词]
[摘要]
目的:评价广域视网膜屈光度地形图仪(Voptica Peripheral Refractor,VPR)在散瞳条件下测量中央及周边视网膜屈光度的重复性,以及其与检影镜测量结果的一致性。 方法:采用前瞻性自身对照设计,纳入80例受试者的80只右眼。全部受试者在0.5%托品卡胺散瞳后,于13个预设视场点位接受VPR连续3次测量和检影镜测量。以等效球镜度(spherical equivalent refraction,SER)进行分析。近轴区域(中心及±5°)以两法差值绝对值≤0.50 D判定一致,中部(±15°)和边缘(±25°)区域以≤1.00 D判定一致。以组内标准差(Sw)、重测重复性(TRT=2.77×Sw)和组内相关系数(ICC)评价VPR重复性;以3次VPR测量均值与检影读数进行Bland-Altman分析。 结果:受试者实际年龄范围为7.95~36.56岁,散瞳后自动验光SER范围为?8.75~+3.25 D;未成年人17例,高度近视者7例。近轴区域一致375/400个点位,一致率为93.75%(95%CI:90.70%~96.80%),其95%CI下限高于预设65%最低可接受值(单侧P<0.001);中部和边缘区域一致率分别为98.13%和93.44%。13个点位ICC为0.970~0.998,TRT为0.59~2.08 D。Bland-Altman分析显示,周边点位95%一致性界限较中央点位宽。 结论:在散瞳条件下,VPR在本研究年龄及屈光范围内测量中央和周边SER的重复性较好,与检影法的一致率较高,但部分边缘点位的测量变异较大。其在儿童、老年及高度屈光不正人群和非散瞳条件下的测量性能仍需进一步验证。
[Key word]
[Abstract]
Objective: To evaluate the within-device repeatability of a wide-field retinal refractometer (VPR) and its agreement with streak retinoscopy for central and peripheral refraction under cycloplegia. Methods: This prospective self-controlled study included 80 right eyes of 80 participants. After cycloplegia with 0.5% tropicamide, refraction was measured at 13 predefined visual-field locations using three consecutive VPR measurements and retinoscopy. Spherical equivalent refraction (SER) was analyzed. Agreement was defined as an absolute intermethod difference of no more than 0.50 D in the paraxial region (center and ±5°) and no more than 1.00 D in the mid-peripheral (±15°) and peripheral (±25°) regions. Within-subject standard deviation (Sw), test-retest repeatability (TRT = 2.77 × Sw), and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) were used to assess repeatability. Bland-Altman analysis compared the mean of the three VPR measurements with the retinoscopy reading. Results: Participants were 7.95 to 36.56 years old, and cycloplegic autorefraction SER ranged from ?8.75 to +3.25 D. Seventeen participants were minors and seven had high myopia. In the paraxial region, 375 of 400 locations agreed, for an agreement rate of 93.75% (95% CI, 90.70% to 96.80%); the lower confidence limit exceeded the prespecified minimum acceptable rate of 65% (one-sided P < 0.001). Agreement rates were 98.13% in the mid-peripheral region and 93.44% in the peripheral region. ICCs across the 13 locations ranged from 0.970 to 0.998, and TRT ranged from 0.59 to 2.08 D. Bland-Altman limits of agreement were wider at peripheral than at central locations. Conclusion: Under cycloplegia, VPR showed good repeatability and high agreement with retinoscopy within the study population, with greater variability peripherally. Validation in children, older adults, highly ametropic patients, and noncycloplegic settings is still needed.
[中图分类号]
[基金项目]